Popeyes Spicy Mayo Sauce (Copycat Recipe)

If you’re a fan of the spicy and smoky flavors of Popeyes spicy mayo sauce, then you’re going to love copycat Popeyes spicy mayo sauce recipe!

This healthier rendition of spicy mayo sauce tastes like a fiesta in your mouth. If you love Popeyes spicy chicken sandwich then you have to try this sauce!

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you. See my Affiliate Disclosure to read my policy and more about affiliate links.

Table of Contents

• Why You’ll Love Popeyes Spicy Mayo Sauce Copycat Recipe
• What’s Popeyes Spicy Sauce Made of?
• Ingredients For Popeyes Spicy Mayo Sauce
• How to Make Popeyes Spicy Mayo Sauce
• How Long Does Spicy Mayo Sauce Last?
• Ingredient Substitutions
• Can You Freeze Popeyes Spicy Mayo Sauce
• Is Popeyes Spicy Mayo Sauce Gluten Free?
• Can I Make Spicy Mayo Sauce Without Mayo?
• How To Use This Spicy Mayo Sauce Recipe
• Common Questions and Answers About Popeyes
• Popeyes Spicy Chicken Sandwich
• More Sauce Recipes to Try

Why You’ll Love Popeyes Spicy Mayo Sauce Copycat Recipe

This fiery and creamy sauce replicates the beloved Popeyes flavor. With a perfect balance of heat, tang, and creaminess, it’s ideal for sandwiches, burgers, fries, and as a dip. Made with mayonnaise, onion powder, chipotle chilis in adobo sauce etc., this vibrant sauce packs a punch of flavor.

You can adjust the spice level to your liking and enjoy the fiery kick it adds to your favorite dishes. Best of all this recipe is healthy! You can make it with real mayo or turn it vegan by using a vegan mayo.

Spicy mayo sauce is:

• Keto Friendly
• Low Carb
• Gluten Free
• Vegan Friendly
• Vegetarian
• Paleo
• Nut Free
• Soy Free
• Can be made dairy free
• Quick and easy

What’s Popeyes Spicy Sauce Made of?

Even though you might love the great taste of Popeyes spicy mayo sauce, I don’t recommend eating it. Popeyes doesn’t even print the ingredients of their food on the website or on store menus. After some digging around I was able to find out exactly what spicy mayo is made from.

Authentic Popeyes Spicy Mayo Ingredients:

• soybean oil, distilled vinegar, egg yolks water, sugar, salt, calcium disodium, monosodium glutamate, EDTA, natural flavor, capsicums, garlic, salt, calcium chloride, sodium benzoate and natural flavors.

So as you can see the spicy mayo sauce is completely riddled with preservatives including MSG (monosodium glutamate).

That’s why you should make this recipe at home. Not only will it be tastier, but it’s much healthier as well.

Ingredients For Popeyes Spicy Mayo Sauce

Now that we see what awful the real spicy mayo sauce at Popeyes is made from. Let’s check out the ingredients for my copycat version.

• Mayo (vegan or regular)
• Chipotle Chilis in Adobo Sauce
•  Apple Cider Vinegar
• Sugar (optional)
• Onion Powder
• Mustard Powder
• Smoked Paprika
• Chili Powder
• Sea Salt

How to Make Popeyes Spicy Mayo Sauce

• In a mixing bowl, combine the mayo, apple cider vinegar, and chipotles in adobo .
• Add the onion powder, mustard powder, paprika, chili powder, and salt to the mixing bowl.Stir all the ingredients until they are fully combined. Taste the sauce and adjust the salt and chili powder as needed to suit your taste.

How Long Does Spicy Mayo Sauce Last?

Homemade spicy mayo sauce typically lasts for about 1 week when stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator.

However, it’s important to note that the exact shelf life may vary depending on the freshness of the ingredients used and the specific conditions of your refrigerator.

Always use your best judgment and discard the sauce if you notice any signs of spoilage, such as an off smell or unusual texture.

Ingredient Substitutions

• Chipotle Chilis in Adobo Sauce: If you don’t have chipotle chilis you can use Sriracha sauce.
• Apple Cider Vinegar: You can use white wine vinegar instead.
• Mustard Powder: Use regular mustard instead.
• Smoked Paprika: Regular paprika will also work well.
• Chili Powder: Red pepper chili flakes work well.

Can You Freeze Popeyes Spicy Mayo Sauce

No you cannot freeze this spicy mayo sauce because mayo separates when it’s frozen. The thawed out results will be grainy and watery. It’s best to enjoy spicy mayo sauce within one week of making it.

Is Popeyes Spicy Mayo Sauce Gluten Free?

Upon reviewing the ingredients in Popeyes spicy mayo sauce I can say that the sauce itself appears to be gluten free. But I’m skeptical to trust that since the sauce isn’t listed on their gluten free menu.

I could only assume that the sauce is cross contaminated by trace amounts of gluten due to one of the processed ingredients.

While a typical spicy aioli is gluten free I cannot say with certainty if the spicy mayo sauce is gluten free. So it’s best to avoid it if you are on a gluten free diet or have celiacs disease.

Can I Make Spicy Mayo Sauce Without Mayo?

You can definitely make spicy mayo sauce without mayo. Here are some options to use instead:

• Vegan Mayo
• Vegan Sour Cream
• Regular Sour Cream
• Greek Yogurt
• Plain Coconut Yogurt
• Plain Sheep Yogurt

All of these options will provide the creamy tanginess needed for this recipe.

How To Use This Spicy Mayo Sauce Recipe

Spicy mayo sauce is a versatile condiment that adds a tangy and spicy kick to various dishes. Here are some popular ways to use spicy mayo sauce:

1. As a Dip: Spicy mayo is commonly used as a dipping sauce for appetizers such as french fries, chicken wings, sushi rolls, dumplings, and spring rolls.
2. Burger and Sandwich Spread: Spicy mayo makes an excellent spread for burgers, sandwiches, and wraps.
3. Sushi and Poke Bowls: Spicy mayo is a staple in sushi restaurants, particularly for rolls like the spicy tuna roll or spicy salmon roll. I
4. Tacos and Wraps: Use spicy mayo as a sauce for tacos and wraps. It pairs well with grilled chicken, shrimp, fish, or even vegetarian fillings. Drizzle or spread it on the tortillas along with your other desired toppings.
5. Seafood Sauce: Spicy mayo is a fantastic accompaniment to seafood dishes. Serve it alongside fried calamari, shrimp, crab cakes, or grilled fish for a zesty and spicy flavor combination.
6. Salad Dressing: Create a spicy twist on your salads by using spicy mayo as a dressing. Thin it out with a bit of water or lime juice and drizzle it over your greens for an extra kick.
7. Roasted Vegetables: Add a flavorful finishing touch to roasted vegetables by tossing them with some spicy mayo before serving. It can bring a creamy, spicy element to dishes like roasted Brussels sprouts, cauliflower, or sweet potatoes.

Common Questions and Answers About Popeyes

Does Popeyes have mayo?

Popeyes doesn’t have plain mayo but mayo is used as an ingredient in some of their sauces including the Spicy Mayo Sauce.

What is Popeyes batter made of?

Popeyes buttermilk batter is made of Enriched bleached wheat flour, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid, salt, natural spices including mustard and paprika, dried whole egg, dried garlic, onion powder, sugar and Yellow #5, #6 and Red #3. You’ll also find nonfat dried milk, sodium bicarbonate, powdered cellulose, natural chicken flavor, yeast extract, dextrose, whey, milk powder, maltodextrin, modified food starch, silicone dioxide, corn syrup solids, yellow corn flower, buttermilk solids, vinegar powder corn starch and sodium aluminum sulfate.

Is the Popeyes Buffalo Sandwich Spicy?

The Popeyes Buffalo Sandwich is less spicy than the spicy Chicken Sandwich. I would say that it has a mild to medium level of spiciness.

Is Popeyes Ghost pepper spicy?

Popeyes ghost pepper is pretty spicy. It will definitely burn your mouth and the skin around your mouth. If you enjoy spicy foods the ghost pepper wings are for you. But if you prefer a more mild meal I would stay away!

Popeyes Spicy Chicken Sandwich

The Popeyes Spicy Chicken Sandwich is one of the most popular items on their menu. Here are some common questions and answers about this coveted chicken sandwich.

Does Popeyes Spicy Chicken Sandwich have spicy breading?

Yes the breading in the spicy chicken sandwich is spicy because it’s made with spicy seasoning.

What makes Popeyes spicy sandwich spicy?

Popeyes spicy chicken sandwich is made spicy by the spicy mayo and the spicy marinade used to marinate the chicken before it’s deep fried. The marinade is made from hot sauce and other spices.

Popeyes Spicy Chicken Sandwich nutrition facts:

Serving Size: One Spicy Chicken Sandwich

• Calories 700
• Fat 42 grams
• Saturated Fat 14 grams
• Trans Fat 1.5 grams
• Cholesterol 90 miligrams
• Sodium 1,634.6 miligrams
• Carbohydrates 50 grams
• Fiber 2 grams
• Sugar 8 grams
• Proteins 28 grams

More Sauce Recipes to Try

If you love this spicy mayo recipe you’re going to love these other dips and sauce recipes to try at home!